Reviewers were broadly positive about the redesigned P.Series, especially the P.3, and several outlets framed it as one of the better-executed dirt jumpers currently available. Bike Magazine described the bike as light, responsive, and an "absolute delight" on asphalt and dirt, while NSMB emphasized the quality of the Marzocchi DJ fork, calling out its "100mm of rock hard plushness" as a major reason the bike feels composed on hard landings. Across reviews, the P.Series was consistently characterized as snappy, playful, and rewarding for riders who actively pump, manual, and move the bike rather than simply letting it smooth over terrain. Reviewers also liked the redesign’s logic: the wheel-size-based lineup, cleaner frame layout, and the unusual inclusion of derailleur and dropper compatibility on what is still a jump-bike platform.
The criticisms were just as consistent. Multiple reviewers singled out the SRAM Level T rear brake as a weak point, describing it as noisy, underpowered, and difficult to modulate. Stock Specialized Kicker tires were praised for rolling quickly on hardpack, wood, and pavement, but some testers found them underwhelming in loose conditions or less confidence-inspiring on hard trick landings, with one reporting a buckled bead. Reviewers also noted that the P.Series is not especially forgiving: compared with a modern trail hardtail, the P.3 in particular can feel twitchy in the air and demands better timing and balance. Blister and others saw real versatility in the frame design, especially on the P.4, but the consensus was that this remains a niche tool first and foremost—a very good one, but still best suited to pump tracks, skateparks, jump lines, and skills riding rather than conventional trail use.